The Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday kickoff of the U.S. holiday shopping season showed the increasing preference for online purchases, as more Americans opted to stay home and use their smartphones while sales and traffic at brick-and-mortar stores declined.
The ongoing shift to online shopping has forced retailers across the country to invest heavily in boosting their e-commerce businesses and also highlights the impact of early holiday promotions and year-round deals on consumer spending.
The weekend also redefined the importance of Black Friday. For the past few years, Black Friday was believed to be waning in importance, but it is now turning into a day when shoppers do not necessarily flock to stores but spend heavily online.
Bill Park, a partner at Deloitte & Touche LP, said online sales are starting to complement in-store shopping over the weekend, and for shoppers and retailers the two platforms are starting to converge.
This is happening more and more as retailers like Walmart Inc and Amazon.com Inc sell both online and through stores, making winning the transaction more important than where it occurs, retail consultants and analysts said.
Online sales rose more than 23 percent, crossing $6 billion on Black Friday, according to data from Adobe Analytics, which tracks transactions at 80 of the top 100 U.S. retailers. On Thanksgiving, it estimated sales grew 28 percent to $3.7 billion.
Preliminary data from analytics firm RetailNext showed net sales at brick-and-mortar stores fell 4 to 7 percent over the two days, while traffic fell 5 to 9 percent, continuing the trend of recent years. No data was yet available for actual spending in stores.
Products from Amazon.com
- Price: $889.97Was: $999.99
- Price: $604.25Was: $719.99
- Price: $478.93Was: $599.99
In 2017, brick-and-mortar sales were down 8.9 percent for the weekend year-over-year, and shopper traffic fell 4.4 percent. In 2016, store sales were down 4.2 percent and traffic was down 4.4 percent, according to RetailNext. The decrease in store foot traffic is a little greater than it has been in years past, though still within expectations, RetailNext spokesperson Ray Hartjen said.
Data from retail research firm ShopperTrak also showed that visits to stores fell a combined 1 percent during Thanksgiving and Black Friday compared with the same days in 2017.
Walmart does offer product care plans and a trade-in program that allows shoppers to exchange devices for gift cards. But one Walmart employee of nine years told Business Insider that it was a mistake for customers to just assume “we have an electronics repair facility here.”
An associate of 12 years told Business Insider that it was a mistake to wait “until the last minute to shop,” especially when it comes to busier times of the week or year. The employee added that some shoppers fail to understand that “they aren’t the only people that will show up. So, yes, there will be lines at the registers. Plan better — plan early.”
A Walmart store manager told the savings-oriented blog The Krazy Coupon Lady that there’s a way to return products ordered online with less hassle. If you end up ordering an item on Walmart.com that you don’t actually want, you can return it through the chain’s mobile express returns system.
“You just get a QR code from your Walmart app, bring your item to the store, skip the line, and scan your QR code on the credit card machine,” according to The Krazy Coupon Lady.
Being mean to Walmart associates
A Walmart employee of 15 years said that “being mean” to the employees at Walmart is probably the biggest mistake a shopper can make.
“If you are nice to them, they will bend over backward to help you,” the employee told Business Insider.
That means acting courteously and not threatening to “contact management or the home office” when something goes wrong that’s outside of the employees’ control, according to an associate of 11 years.
“Unfortunately, there is a bad stigma surrounding Walmart employees,” former Walmart employee Crystal Linn wrote on Quora.
They added that customers sometimes buy into that bias and treat the associates as “ignorant high school drop-outs.”
Products from Amazon.com
- Acer Aspire E 15, 15.6" Full HD, 8th Gen Intel Core i3-8130U, 6GB RAM Memory, 1TB HDD, 8X DVD, E5-576-392HPrice: $354.99Was: $379.99
“I even had a woman ask me once, ‘Do you even know what an electric can opener is?’ after I showed her where the handheld ones were located,” Linn wrote. “Not everyone is like this, of course, but it seems that the large majority have this idea in their mind that anyone that works at Walmart is trashy. The way that people treat you because of that really wears you down.”
Forgetting to check for markdowns
Want to save some money on your next Walmart run? Watch out for the prices.
Specifically, keep an eye out for price tags ending in 0 or 1.
According to an interview with a Walmart store manager on The Krazy Coupon Lady, a price tag ending with a 0 or a 1 denotes a “final markdown price.” Meanwhile, the store manager told the blog that prices ending in 5 “are the first markdown price.”
Brian Field, senior director of advisory services at ShopperTrak, said online sales have eroded traffic from retailers over the years, “but what we have noticed is that the decline is starting to flatten out … Overall it is been consistent with where it’s been over the last few years.”
In 2017, visits to physical stores on Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday were down 1.6 percent, according to the firm. “This decline feels pretty good to me. I think retail is in for a good season,” Field said.
Retail consultants have said spending patterns over the weekend are not as indicative of the entire season as they were a few years ago the tendency now is to spread shopping over November and December.
The National Retail Federation forecast U.S. holiday retail sales in November and December will increase between 4.3 and 4.8 percent over 2017, for a total of $717.45 billion to $720.89 billion.
That compares with an average annual increase of 3.9 percent over the past five years.
(Reporting by Nandita Bose and Melissa Fares in New York, Editing by Gary McWilliams and Leslie Adler)